icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 23, s. 125, p. 109

Cat. Sotheby, 13. December, 1982, no. 269. One-Piece Amphorae; Panel Amphorae. Other. Fill. Well. Dump. E. Vanderpool, Hesperia 7, 1938, p. 376, no. 7, fig. 11. Brommer, Heldensage (3), pp. 382-386. T ... Agora 23 109 P 24964 P 1234 P 3575 P 13782 P 12380 P 1237 P 26533 P 4305 P 13036 P 22216 G 6:3 E 14:11 U 25:2 H 12:6 T 18:3 Q 10:1 ... 550-540 B.C ... E. Vanderpool, Hesperia 7, 1938, p. 376, no. 7, fig. 11 ... T. L. Shear, Hesperia 8, 1939, p. 233 and p. 234, fig. 31

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 442, p. 403

Dèlos XXVII, D 54, p. 248, pl. 43. Samos XIV, p. 121, fig. 200A, Z 133:B. Anderson, 1954, nos. 151, 199, pp. 148, 150, fig. 17. Phrygia III, p. 134, pl. 27:e. Cistern. Samaria III, p. 342, no. 7, fig ... Agora 29 403 P 24821 P 8068 P 31932 P 31961 P 20228 P 31962 P 4074 P 3429 P 20702 P 3428 P 20701 P 19724 P 26048 E 15:4 O 17:7 H 16:4 F 15:2 R 10:1 O 17:6 ... 200-125 B.C ... C-G 5-10 ... A-E 16-23

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 26, s. 14, p. xiv

F.W. Imhoof-Blumer and P. Gardner, Ancient Coins Illustrating Lost Masterpieces of Greek Art: A Numismatic Commentary on Pausanias, new enlarged ed., with introduction, commentary, and notes by A.N. Oikonomides, ... Agora 26 xiv ... Agora 26, s. 14, p. xiv

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 32, p. xxxii

Rotroff, S.I. 1984a. Ceramic Workshops in Hellenistic Athens, in Ancient Greek and Related Pottery: Proceedings of the International Vase Symposium in Amsterdam 12-15 April 1984 (Allard Pierson Series ... Agora 29 xxxii ... Agora 29.1, s. 32, p. xxxii

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 30, s. 341, p. 322

ARV² 186, 50. Addenda 188. ARV² 461, 24. ARV² 860, 5. CVA, Berlin 3, Deutschland 22, pl. 104 [1033]. ARV² 860, 9. Addenda 298. ARV² 862, 24. Addenda and Corrigenda, p. 915 to ARV1 234-237. Addenda and ... Agora 30 322 P 14968 P 9282 P 14663 P 3694 P 1589 P 3051 P 7356 P 13215 P 17788 M 17:4 G 3:1 E 3:1 ... 490-480 B.C ... Agora 30, s. 341, p. 322

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 22, s. 90, p. 73

Cistern. Thompson C 20. Fill. Other. Well. Hausmann, pls. 2-9. Hausmann, pl. 2:1. Courby, p. 347, fig. 71:28b, n. Thompson C 19. Courby, p. 347, fig. 71:28f-h. Walters, footnote 39, p. 22, p. 252, G 98 ... Agora 22 73 P 4101 P 22978 P 13685 P 20484 P 22192 P 25413 P 406 P 28535 P 23039 P 2432 P 404 N 20:7 M-N 15:1 H-K 12-14 G 5:3 Q-R 10-11:1 D-E 8-9:1 ... 225-175 B.C ... Agora 22, s. 90, p. 73 ... Agora 22, no. 234

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 30, s. 14, p. xiv

D. Buitron-Oliver, Douris: A Master-Painter of Athenian Red Figure Vases [Kerameus 9], Mainz 1995. L. Burn, The Meidias Painter, Oxford 1987. D. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques à figures noires ... Agora 30 xiv ... Agora 30, s. 14, p. xiv

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 457, p. 418

Well. Cistern. Rotroff, 1983, no. 195, p. 297, fig. 6 on p. 269, pl. 61. AvP XI, i, nos. 147, 152, 237, pp. 123-124, pls. 43, 48, 65. AvP XI, i, nos. 244, 247, 248, 262, 264, 269, pp. 87-88, pl. 51:2 ... Agora 29 418 P 6757 P 11825 P 5640 P 8573 P 4405 P 21013 P 6861 P 11536 P 10847 P 26075 F 13:3 N 19:1 E 14:3 E 6:2 F 12:3 E 10:1 E 5:2 O 17:7 ... 225-150 B.C ... G 5

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 12.2, s. 91, p. 464

Schimmel Collection: Exhibition of the Norbert Schimmel Collection, Fogg Art Museum of Harvard University, November 15, 1964 to February 14, 1965. ed. H. Hoffman. Mainz, 1964, no. 25. Spon, J., and Wheler, ... Agora 12 464 ... Supplementum Epigraphicum Graecum' Leyden (S.E.G.), XIV, 1957, p. 67, 303 ... (S.C.E.), IV, 2: E. Gjerstad, The ... E. Gjerstad, J. Lindros, E. Sjöqvist, A. Westolm,

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 7, s. 15, p. xiv

Thompson, H. A., "Pnyx and Thesmophorion," Hesperia, V, 1936, cf. pp. 169, 197. Agora 2. Thompson, Margaret, "Some Unpublished Bronze Money of the Early Eighth Century," Hesperia, IX, 1940, pp. 358-380 ... Agora 7 xiv ... Agora 7, s. 15, p. xiv

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 12.2, s. 78, p. 451

Catling, H.W., Cypriot Bronzework in the Mycenaean World, Oxford, 1963, figs. 17-18. Clara Rhodes, studi e materiale pubblicati a cura dell' Istituto Storico-Archaeologico di Rodi, Rhodes, 1923-1941, VIII ... Agora 12 451 ... Agora 12.2, s. 78, p. 451

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 421, p. 382

Pollitt, 1979, no. XIV.5, p. 217, pl. 67:a. Cistern. Well. Fill. Pollitt, 1979, p. 220, deposit XXVII. Dentzer, 1982, R 315, p. 605, pl. 93, fig. 564. D.B. Thompson, 1952b, no. 87, p. 164, pl. 42. Délos ... Agora 29 382 P 4068 P 13554 P 22288 T 888 P 19680 P 5653 P 17917 P 13555 P 16850 P 6162 P 26519 P 19535 P 26429 P 14041 P 17703 P 7812 P 16124 P 15163 Lot ΕΛ 62 H 16:3 O 18:2 J 11:1 E 14:3 D 15:3 S 19:3 ... 4th B.C ... Pollitt, 1979, no. XIV.5, p. 217, pl. 67:a

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 14, s. 26, p. 1

The Athenian Agora; Volume 014; The Agora of Athens; The History; Shape and Uses of an Ancient City Centre; Before Solon. Thucydides, II, 15, 3. A.W. Gomme, A Historical Commentary on Thucydides, II, Oxford, ... Agora 14 1 ... G.E. Mylonas, Eleusis and the Eleusinian ... 24-29, 53, 63, 234

[Agora Object] Agora XXX, no. 234

Four non-joining fragments of rim and neck, P 25978 a preserving the spiral of one handle, P 28759 with start of shoulder. Two small fragments (P 25978 b and c) give a bit of the flange of a handle and ... Ca. 500-490 B.C ... are set in a frieze: e.g., Munich 2381; Oxford G. 136.36 ... 1994, p. 937, no. 185, s

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 26, s. 323, p. 297

The Athenian Agora; Volume 26; The Greek Coins; Deposits Including Hoards; Outside the Agora. The Athenian Agora; Volume 26; The Greek Coins; Deposits Including Hoards; Outside the Agora; Olynthos. Olynthus ... Agora 26 297 ... Robinson II, G.E. Mylonas and D ... S.I. Rotroff, Olynthus and Other Deposits-The Pottery (lecture, Boston 1989), ... S.I. Rotroff, Athenian Hellenistic Pottery: Towards a Firmer Chronology, Acten des

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 384, p. 345

Cistern. Drain. Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 33, p. 234, fig. 4, pl. 32. Well. Agora 21, F 156, p. 40, pl. 18. Agora 27, no. 10, p. 181, ill. 35, pl. 41 ... Agora 29 345 P 7378 P 29327 P 10687 P 7753 P 73687 P 7712 P 7364 P 24041 P 26960 P 28131 P 2523 P 6961 P 6215 P 4450 P 7342 P 2529 P 7754 P 20987 P 7757 P 7756 E 3:1 F 16:8 P 10:1 H 14:2 F 16:1 D-E 8-9:1 ... 325-290 B.C ... Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 33, p. 234, fig. 4, pl. 32

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 393, p. 354

Morrow, 1985, pp. 95-96, pl. 76. H.A. Thompson, 1934, E 57, p. 398, fig. 86. Michaelides, 1994, p. 321, pl. 249:γ. Cistern. CVA, Hoppin and Gallatin Collections 1 [USA 1], pl. 30 [51]:7. Hausmann, 1962, ... Agora 29 354 P 3176 P 1435 P 9669 P 19043 P 16675 P 28679 L 5270 P 7388 P 18338 F 15:2 N 19:1 L 19:2 J 5:1 E 3:1 A-B 19-20:1 ... 140-125 B.C ... Agora 29.1, s. 393, p. 354

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 379, p. 340

Cistern. H.A. Thompson, 1934, C 53, p. 365, fig. 49. Rotroff, 1983, no. 34, p. 287, pl. 54. Well. Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 31, p. 234, fig. 4, pl. 32. Agora 12, no. 839, p. 296, pl. 33 ... Agora 29 340 P 867 P 14353 P 7752 P 6274 P 1988 P 28740 P 1077 P 7362 P 3500 P 11208 P 7711 P 28021 P 19977 P 27229 P 7710 P 27985 P 14352 P 2530 P 28020 E 3:1 H 6:9 E 14:1 J 5:1 I 17:5 B 13:1 F 11:2 F ... 300-250 ... E 3:1 ... E 14:1 ... E 29:1

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 25, s. 15, p. xv

Meister, I. K., "Zum Zeitpunkt des Einführung des Ostrakismos," Chiron 1, 1971, pp. 85-88. Oliver, J. H., "Reforms of Cleisthenes," Historia 9, 1960, pp. 503-507. J. Kirchner, Prosopographia attica, Berlin ... Agora 25 xv ... Agora 25, s. 15, p. xv

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 416, p. 377

Cistern. Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 64, p. 238, pl. 34. Votives and Other Vessels for Religious Use. Schefold, 1934, no. 299, p. 35, pl. 49. Kerameikos XIV, no. 119:35, p. 118, pl. 51:3. Belin de Ballu, ... Agora 29 377 P 8414 P 27979 P 26853 P 284 P 17461 P 22870 P 6756 P 26260 P 11837 P 15260 Lot Δ 20 D 11:2 F 16:8 E 14:1 F 13:3 M 18:10 N 19:1 A-B 19-20:1 ... 3rd B.C ... E 14:1

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 23, s. 254, p. 238

Lekythoi; The Lekythos Painters IV; The Class of Athens 581; i or ii. Well. The Class of Athens 581; i or ii. Paralip. 241. Paralip. 234. The Class of Athens 581; i or ii; The Kalinderu Group. Paralip ... Agora 23 238 P 24333 P 24335 P 24435 P 24447 P 24371 P 24421 P 24397 P 24464 P 24485 P 1311 P 24488 Q 12:3 G 6:3 ... Early 5th B.C ... G 6:3

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 30, s. 284, p. 265

Well. ARV² 1247, 1. Paralip. 469, 1. Lezzi-Hafter, Eretria-Maler, p. 342, cat. no. 234, pls. 144, 145. Pit. ARV² 1253, 58. Lezzi-Hafter, p. 321, cat. no. 76, pl. 57. Addenda 354. ARV² 1253, 59. Lezzi-Hafter, ... Agora 30 265 P 5496 P 10122 P 7296 P 5262 P 22146 P 5264 P 5245 P 5265 P 10550 P 8929 P 355 P 21536 E 13:1 M 20:3 C 12:3 G 12:21 B 15:1 M 18:8 P 8:2 ... 3rd quarter 5th B.C ... Agora 30, s. 284, p. 265

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 177, p. 138

Tarsus I, no. 87, p. 217, figs. 123, 182. PF II, D 33-D 51, pp. 48-49, 60-61, pls. 13, 14. AvP I, ii, p. 273, Beiblatt 36:5, 37:1, 4. AvP IX, pp. 119-120, pl. 57:c:5, h, i, 1. AvP XI, i, 191, p. 130, pl ... Agora 29 138 Lot ΣΑ 430 Lot ΡΡ 591 Lot ΡΡ 592 Lot ΡΡ 593 Lot ΡΡ 594 Lot ΡΡ 595 Lot ΡΡ 596 Lot ΡΡ 597 Lot ΡΡ 598 Lot ΠΘ 347 Q 10:1 R 13:9 B 13:8 ... Agora 29.1, s. 177, p. 138

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 380, p. 341

H.A. Thompson, 1934, A 21, p. 318. Cistern. Well. Agora 12, no. 841, p. 296, fig. 8, pl. 33. Jones, Graham, and Sackett, 1973, p. 377, under no. 28. Agora 27, no. 107, pp. 180-181, pl. 40. Pit. Rotroff, ... Agora 29 341 P 1831 P 7746 P 10452 P 7747 P 20315 P 4704 P 16217 P 7326 P 7363 P 22025 P 28018 P 29328 P 19708 P 6271 P 11243 P 1078 P 1830 P 23409 P 7808 P 18717 P 7191 P 22189 P 2863 P 16273 P 7748 P ... 290-275 B.C ... Agora 29.1, s. 380, p. 341

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 8, s. 92, p. 78

Fragment of Stand; Early Protoattic. Matz, Gesch. Gr. Kunst., pls. 198-199. Fill. Burr 333. Fragment of an Oinochoe; Early Protoattic. Fragment of Closed Pot; Early Protoattic. Burr 210. B.S.A., XXXV, ... Agora 8 78 P 2435 P 754 P 13280 P 24032 P 21288 P 10229 P 16831 P 26411 P 873 H 8-10 H 17:4 H 12:9 J 15:1 T 19:3 R 17:5 ... Geometric-Early 6th B.C ... Hesperia, XIV, 1945, pl. XI, 2 ... B.S.A., XXXV, 1934-1935, p. 215 ... B.S.A., XXXV, 1934-1935, pl. 44

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 9, s. 19, p. 11

N.K. Alexopoulos, art. Τρίπολις in Μεγάλη Έλληνική Ἐγκυκλοπαίδεια, Athens, 1933, Vol. 23. F. Basinger, Mehmed der Eroberer und seine Zeit, Munich, 1953=Mahomet le conquérant et son temps, Paris, 1954=Maometto ... Agora 9 11 ... Agora 9, s. 19, p. 11

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 450, p. 411

H.A. Thompson, 1934, B 26, p. 339, fig. 19. Agora 12, p. 275, under no. 561. Cistern. Kabirion III, no. 218, p. 133, pl. 12, no. 171, p. 132, pl. 9. Bohtz and Albert, 1975, no. 28a, p. 516, fig. 53. PF ... Agora 29 411 P 4067 P 4567 P 28125 P 9328 P 28754 P 31949 P 488 P 12085 P 10173 Lot Γ 102 Lot ΛΛ 55 H 16:3 F 16:8 M 18:2 P 21:4 C 10:1 N 20:6 ... 225-190 B.C ... Samos XIV, p. 157, fig. 256:F ... PF VI, p. 17, Group E

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 14, s. 265, p. 240

Kratinos, Frag. 323 (Kock and Edmonds). Kratippos, Frag. 3 (Jacoby, F.G.H., no. 64). Lycian, Anacharsis, 7. Lycian, Dialogi Meretricii, 8, 7. Lycian, Iupitter Tragoedus, 15, 16, 32, 33. Lykourgos, Leokrates, ... Agora 14 240 ... Kratippos, Frag. 3 (Jacoby, F.G.H., no. 64) ... Philochoros, Frag. 30 (Jacoby, F.G.H., no. 328) ... Menekles-Kallikrates, Frag. 2 (Jacoby, F.G.H., no. 370)

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 316, p. 277

Braun, 1970, no. 85, p. 140, fig. 2, pl. 56:5. Cistern. Rotroff, 1991, no. 54, p. 81, pl. 29. H.A. Thompson, 1934, C 7, p. 348, fig. 29. Rotroff, 1991, no. 22, p. 71, pl. 19. Rotroff, 1991, no. 56, p ... Agora 29 277 P 14304 P 26886 P 4002 P 5814 P 26887 P 31875 P 747 P 31879 P 31876 N 20:7 E 3:1 G 6:2 E 14:1 M 18:10 N 20:6 I 17:5 ... 280-260 B.C ... Agora 29.1, s. 316, p. 277

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 378, p. 339

Well. Agora 12, no. 837, p. 296, fig. 8. Jones, Graham, and Sackett 1973, p. 380, under no. 37. Cistern. H.A. Thompson, 1934, B 15, p. 337, fig. 18 and fig. 115 on p. 431. H.A. Thompson, 1934, A 14, pp ... Agora 29 339 P 4449 P 7749 P 28029 P 7696 P 28135 P 4383 P 7750 P 4063 P 7751 P 1834 P 868 P 2524 P 9349 P 26948 P 28742 P 6367 P 28741 P 4428 P 28419 P 28130 P 6955 F 11:2 F 16:8 E 3:1 F 12:3 H 16:3 G ... 300 B.C ... Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 32, p. 234, fig. 4, pl. 32

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 386, p. 347

Cistern. Fill. Well. Agora 12, no. 948, p. 303, pl. 34. Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 38, p. 234, pl. 32. Agora 12, no. 949, p. 303, pl. 34. Jones, Graham, and Sackett, 1973, p. 377, under no. 32. Pit. Agora ... Agora 29 347 P 20860 P 22885 P 6273 P 30795 P 7427 P 30801 P 14546 P 19362 P 15231 P 28739 P 25995 P 28023 P 19733 P 6149 P 25685 P 7345 P 7346 P 588 P 7352 P 7366 P 7809 D 17:3 M-N 15:1 E 14:1 R 13:11 ... 300-275 B.C ... Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 38, p. 234, pl. 32

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 8, s. 45, p. 31

Neck Amphora; Late Geometric. Brann L 2. Well. Amphora; Late Geometric. Young XI 1. I.L.N., Oct 13, 1939, p. 648, fig. 5. Kerameikos, V, 1, pl. 116, inv. 821. CVA Mannheim 1, pl. 2, 4. B.S.A., XII, 1905-1906, ... Agora 8 31 P 13767 P 5423 P 12105 P 8216 P 23888 P 21707 P 7492 P 5422 P 6401 P 4990 P 25630 P 25644 P 24032 V 24:2 F 12:2 S 18:1 D 12:3 N 11:6 P 7:3 D 11:5 G 12:24 G 12:19 J 14:5 J 15:1 ... 3rd quarter of 8th B.C ... Jahrb., XIV, 1899, p. 86, figs. 46-47 ... B.S.A., XII, 1905-1906, p. 87, fig. 8 ... B.S.A., XII, 1905-1906, p. 87, fig. 7

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 298, p. 259

Pyre. Romiopoulou, 1967, no. 637, pp. 102-103, fig. 5:β on p. 98. Cistern. Agora 5, p. 64, under K 52, pl. 39. Well. Alt-Ägina II, i, no. 459, p. 67, fig. 52, pl. 34. Shear, 1973, p. 133, note 37, pl ... Agora 29 259 P 13372 P 7760 P 19363 P 18707 P 11239 P 28743 P 29119 P 7379 P 28031 R 18:1 E 3:1 D 16:1 B 13:7 M 21:1 J 5:1 F 16:8 ... 275-260 B.C ... E 3:1

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 11, s. 210, p. 191

Bearded god or hero, "Munich King". Paris, Louvre. Archaic engraved and painted grave stele. Tenea Kouros. Archaistic Athena, Minerva of Poitiers. Tyche, archaistic. Archaistic dancers from theater at ... Agora 11 191 ... Paris, Louvre G 234 ... Paris, Louvre G 103 ... Paris, Louvre G 229

icon

[Agora Object] I 4408: Record Fragments

Inscribed fragments. "POLETAI" record. Confiscated property of those who profaned the Mysteries. Fragment ΙΙ 2 a), inscribed face only preserved. Thirteen lines of the inscription preserved. Belongs to ... 414 B.C ... fragm.) S 21 g) (ΒΒ 29) S 21 h) ... ΙΙ 260 e), inscribed face ... joined. Fragment ΒΒ 29 g

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 355, p. 316

Pit. Cistern. Agora 12, no. 1076, p. 311, fig. 10. Agora 27, no. 120, pp. 182, 184, pl. 41. Well. Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 39, p. 234, fig. 5, pl. 32. Vanderpool, McCredie, and Steinberg, 1962, no ... Agora 29 316 P 25687 P 30951 P 7730 P 7703 P 20318 P 400 P 11241 P 11287 P 28134 P 6239 P 865 P 20920 P 866 P 30941 P 18737 A 17:3 E 3:1 H 6:4 B 13:7 B 13:8 F 16:8 E 14:1 H 6:9 R 13:9 M 21:1 ... 275 B.C ... Agora 29.1, s. 355, p. 316

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 14, s. 198, p. 173

Isocrates, VII, 15. Lysias, XXIV, 20. The Athenian Agora; Volume 014; The Agora of Athens; The History; Shape and Uses of an Ancient City Centre; Commercial Domestic and Industrial Quarters; Houses. Judeich, ... Agora 14 173 ... Agora 14, s. 198, p. 173

[Agora Object] Agora XXIX, no. 1718

Banded Fish-plate. Over half of rim, part of floor and foot restored. High foot; beveled resting surface. Floor concave with shallow groove around outer edge and around depression. Rim nearly horizontal, ... Context of 110 to early 1st century after Christ ... Lesbos (e.g. AvP XI, i, nos ... 1972--1975, col. 498; Samos XIV, p ... fig. 6 on p. 269, pl. 61 [E

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 29.1, s. 314, p. 275

Hemispherical Cup and Related Shapes. Shear, 1969, p. 392, pl. 103:d. Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 34, p. 234, pls. 32, 49. Cistern. Rotroff, 1991, no. 59, p. 82, pl. 30. Agora 22, p. 39, note 107. Rotroff, ... Agora 29 275 P 297 P 27986 P 15130 P 17406 P 26839 P 26884 P 26891 P 31802 P 16222 P 26882 P 20207 F 16:8 F 19:2 C 20:3 E 3:1 N 21:4 ... 225-200 B.C ... Stella G. Miller, 1974, no. 34, p. 234, pls. 32, 49

icon

[Agora Publication Page] Agora 9, s. 20, p. 12

Pausanias, VIII, 27, 4. R. Loenertz, Pour l'histoire du Péloponèse au XIVe siècle (1382-1404), Études Byzantines, I., 1943, Bucharest, 1944, pp. 152-196. W. Miller, Essays on the Latin Orient, Cambidge, ... Agora 9 12 ... Agora 9, s. 20, p. 12